Comprehensive coverage

Did humans copy the bowing position from animals?

Who does not know the biblical saying: "Go to the lazy ant, see its ways and be wise" (Proverbs 6:XNUMX), one that has an allegorization and symbolism with a well-deserved educational and social message. And yes, there is nothing to argue about, because in this introduction is hidden a simple message of taking a look at the animal world and drawing some conclusions.

She works at the Keda Kida Sea Center before the whale. Source: gwaar.
An aquarium worker in Japan bowed to a whale. source: gwaar.

Indeed, I know that one of the primordial instincts of dogs is the urge to fetch, long before they were domesticated and adapted to the household on this one and harnessed for hunting purposes on that one. The fact that the three dogs (whose score, by the way, is false, a pinch... and not a false opening, like a plurality of "queen", "slave" and others nearby) that I have "bother" as soon as you enter my residence to bring me an "offering" - some kind of toy such as a bone, a toy, etc. When it's beyond "just" it creates a next one. There is a kind of acknowledgment of my "lordship" (I really didn't like to use this word) as if in terms of affection on the one hand and submission on the other.

So what does this have to do with our case? Well, here and there in my academic research and lectures, and especially in the field of the history of sports and games, I find myself needing to highlight the area of ​​imitation of our ancestors in the behaviors of animals that lived in their midst, in a certain proximity to them, such as the actual sports competitions. And it will be noted here and qualified to a certain extent that in our case it is only one component, out of several, that was the foundation of the birth of sports competitions and their development, i.e. - competitive sports following the behavior of animals in the wild.

Well, in connection with those competitions and in other, historical-primordial contexts, I was very interested in the phenomenon of experiencing and even the voluntary decision of the body and sometimes to the point of "licking" the ground. And what I was very "stunned" to see is that such a phenomenon is found in animals and stands out mainly in the struggle between two males, and perhaps even more so, for the "kindness" of the female for future purposes of the herd, or a fight for territory and carnivore spoils. Sometimes this happens during the fight, sometimes towards its somewhat physical end, and sometimes at the very beginning, when one of the contestants "for the crown", in the phase of mutual examination of the opponent's intentions and physical strength, feels that the results will be known in advance, he "takes" a few steps behind while physically following of submission, a kind of equality. In other words: "I gave up".

And in our case - the phenomenon of people bowing before the king, the lord, the god... expresses a physical, somewhat perfect submission, originating perhaps from clear, accidental observations, animal behavior from this and the internal, immanent, subconscious, natural desire to "go with the strong" from this.

Does this have an educational-political message beyond the description of the actual bowing? Well, according to what is written in my "private", secret, cynical, but true Bible according to my pragmatic assumption, the "verse" is emphasized: "In Genesis man created God", as opposed to the "real" verse, and the text in any case: "Genesis God created man." In both sentences the inferiority of man vis-a-vis God stands out, and especially in the first, as it has an educational and even political/social purpose - to sanctify the status of the priesthood as a ruler, as one who has the absolute truth and even the prerogative to punish, and let's not forget that the Bible was written by mortals.

And how does this relate to our case: check and examine carefully, not only the people of Israel, but also the myths and rituals of other nations: how is God, the creator of man, depicted? Is when innocent, like a tickling rabbit or like a smiling dolphin? no and no! In our sources, the god appears to Ari, Leviathan and even in the Hebrew/Jewish temple itself, cherubim, seraphim and more appear. And the copper snake that Moses brought from Egypt and that no Yahwist reform, even that of Hezekiah and Josiah, was able to remove it from the temple. Scary? gruesome? Kind of like a horror movie, when it's no wonder that the crowd of believers, like soma in the chimney, fall to their feet, bow and vibrate: "Amen and Amen". And what would you say in the face of the fact that the temple itself was built as a model of the image of Harry: wide and large in front and narrow in the back of his body. And what about the phrase/name "Ariel" in the Bible, which is nothing but a connection between Ari and God, or in Latin leo dei, when the Bible says about him: "And the Ariel is twelve (cubits) long and twelve (cubits) wide, square to its four quarters" (Ezekiel Mag, 16). That is, 6.72 m by 6.72 m, and let's not forget that Ezekiel is referring to the Jewish, Yahuist temple, and not to some Assyrian or Babylonian temple. And already in the first chapter, in his vision, or as he said: "...and I saw the visions of God" (Ezekiel 1:11), in which there came out of the fire the likeness of four beasts "...and the likeness of their faces was the face of a man and the face of a lion to the right of the four (like the Egyptian sphinx on the one hand and the Assyrian on the other) and the face of a bull From the left to the four and an eagle's face to the four" (ibid., 10-XNUMX), and for this it will be said that one picture is worth a thousand words. And by the way, a complete waste.

To summarize and conclude, the origin of bowing is probably devoid of our ancestors' observation of the behavior of animals, because why, if there were other physical ways to express submission, was kneeling, bowing chosen as the main expression of man's submission to God.

8 תגובות

  1. Thanks, I enjoyed reading. In all my 25 years I have always associated bowing with a person's most private time when defecating. Something to think about…

  2. Dr. Yechiam Shurk was my history teacher at Rothberg High School in Ramat Hasharon 35 years ago.
    He was and remains a fascinating man.

  3. In ancient times there were many sects in Judaism, and they had different concepts about religion.
    It is possible that some of them believed in God in the form of a bull or a calf or his life was different. This image of God in such a form appears both in the story of the golden calf, and also in the statues of the cherubim that were in the second house after Herod's renovation on the sides of the Ark of the Covenant in the Holy of Holies are depicted as half calf half lion with wings.
    Judaism as it is today, is a continuation of the perception of religion by the Pharisees who did not agree with many things in the form of worship and also with different beliefs that were in the Second Temple which was under the auspices of the Sadducees and the Romans.

  4. The ignorant Yahyam Sorek discovered an image in our sources of God as Levitan, I would love to hear where he found it, and perhaps in his private and secret Bible...
    How easy it is to babble something about man learning from the animal, and write it in a scientific tone, and of course also mix in a pathological hatred for everything related to faith, and you have a 'scholarly' article, and yes, like Ajarud, we didn't forget (even then there were whistle-blowers).

  5. The response of Dr. Yehiam Sorek
    In Khuntilet Ajrod, which is a Yemenite ruin in eastern Sinai, between Kadesh (Barnea) and Tzion Geber, 55 Hebrew inscriptions and impressive and interesting paintings dating from the ninth-eighth centuries BC were discovered. The inscriptions were dedicated to "Jehovah Yemen and his approval" and even an interesting inscription, a kind of Jehovah's blessing "to Obadiah son of Edna, blessed be Jehovah". So right in the text itself.

    Amazing is one of the paintings, in which Jehovah, God, is seen in the form of a calf or a cow, with his tail or penis dangling at the bottom of his thigh. His wife, Asherah, is also in the form of a cow, and her tail is between her legs or perhaps she is also decorated with a male genitalia, which perhaps illustrates the androgynous nature of her, and the Hebrew inscription is "To the Lord of Samaria and her Asherah".

    After all, you have an interesting confirmation of an animal image of God and his wife.

  6. The posture is also found in gorilla monkeys for example.
    Maybe the writer forgot that man evolved from an animal..
    Yesterday I was standing at a bus stop and a driver (RS) screeched to a halt and pounced on an elderly man who was crossing the road not exactly at a crosswalk and delayed him and maybe also said something to him...
    The driver screeched to a halt and got out of the car and approached him with threatening gestures and growls and curses, he did not dare to touch him but with the intention of showing a threat he seemed to get very close to him and "invaded his private space" and brought his face close to him and uttered threats... and when I saw this it crossed my mind that this was behavior of her life, just like two dogs or the gorillas you see in nature movies.

  7. A. Agree with Assaf. We just inherited it.
    B. In humans, a new sign of submission has developed: the submissive gets down on one knee and allows the ruler to place a sword on his shoulder, 3-4 cm from the jugular vein. In Buckingham Palace, the sword used for this purpose is on display for visitors. (The palace is open for visits about a month once every few years, I visited).

  8. Nice …
    But the movement of bowing comes from the need to appear smaller,
    In humans, as in many other animals, the aggressor "inflates" and emphasizes his size
    Whereas the submissive flattens/bows down and looks small
    as a sign of surrender and recognition of the power/size of the aggressor,
    There is no need to copy the gesture from other animals
    Because it exists in the primary history of the human race.

Leave a Reply

Email will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismat to prevent spam messages. Click here to learn how your response data is processed.