Comprehensive coverage

Nils Henrik Abel - a tragic story of the fifth degree

Another story of a genius mathematician who grew up in poverty, wrote his first important mathematical paper at the age of 20 and died at the age of 27, when he was on the verge of fame

Nils Henrik Abel
Nils Henrik Abel

A clear rule is that a culture is based first and foremost on the people who create it and the way in which these people can give the potion of immortality to the group they live in is solely through the written book and education.

The country called Norway boasts of the beauty of its land, which places it among the few countries that we call - a small paradise. Apart from the fact that this is a culture that has enshrined hatred of foreign peoples for hundreds of years, it seems that the rule written above has completely disappeared from its notice. Culture, as defined, began to exist in Norway about ten thousand years ago, but the output resulting from the quality of the people who make up the Norwegian group is incredibly low.

There is a well-known proverb in the Yiddish language that claims that - "When luck comes, set up a throne for him!" ". A great mathematical luck was waiting for the Norwegians only about 200 years ago and they did put a throne for him, but it's a shame that they put it upside down. The following article tells about a culture empty of content that missed out on the kind of luck that only comes once.

Niels Henrik Abel (Niels Henrik Abel) was born in 1802 in Norway to a father who was a politician and a drinker and to a mother who was also a politician who was known for having an incredibly low moral level; How low it was I will leave that to the imagination of my readers. Nils was one of seven children in the horribly poor Abel family because at that time the economic situation in his homeland was very bad. This poverty, which reached the point where the food pantry in their home was empty, led to the fact that Abel's father - who could not afford his son's school expenses - gave him an independent education with the cooperation of a local priest until he reached the age of 13, at which time the family was able to send only Abel and his older brother to study at home The religious book Christiana. Two years before that, the best teachers were taken from there and transferred to a university that was a sort of continuation institution of the previous school, which lowered its educational level to an abysmal low. But he did not turn out to be a particularly successful student and was one of those people with a slight inclination towards mathematics and physics. The year 1817 was the point at which the dam broke for Abel after he had a new math teacher named Brent Holmboë. It is worth noting that Holombi replaced the previous math teacher after Hella punished one of the students so severely that he died.

Shortly after arriving, Hollomby noticed a spark of grief and began filling the young man's stomach with university papers from the mathematical studies of Euler, Newton and their friends and soon realized that this was a lift with tremendous potential. After about a year in which he had his eye on the rising star, Holombi began to direct Abel's ideas specifically towards the work of Lagrange and Laplace.

Unfortunately for Abel, in 1820 his father died in great disgrace as a result of his tendency to a drop of bitterness in a way that exceeded his standards as well as false legal scandals in which he was involved in his last years.

The father, who was the main supporter of the family, also brought down an even more serious financial disaster on his wife and children which actually dropped the academic ground from under Abel's feet. Hollomby did everything he could to help and indeed managed to get Abel a study and subsistence scholarship that gave him the ability to study at Christiana University at the age of 19. At the age of 20, Abel was able to present his first mathematical paper that dealt with one of the most important problems in algebra at the time: solving a fifth degree equation by radicals. In my previous article about the Italian mathematician Tartalia (Tartaglia) I explained in a "sports" example what it means to solve equations of the third degree, and this example is also true here when now the basketball player is supposed to score 5 balls simultaneously with one hand into the basket.

The history of solving equations began back in the days of the Greeks when Pythagoras or one of his students found the general solution for a quadratic equation, then the Italian mathematicians Tartellia, Cardano and Ferrari continued them with a third and fourth degree equation, and now it is Abel's turn to deal with fifth degree equations. The way he took is through a concept called radicals. It is difficult to specify exactly what it is but I will say that in general a radical means a root and hence a solution using a radical is done by using the roots. When we say that an equation has a "root" it means that we found its solution (or solutions) when we equated the equation to 0. For example, the expression X2-1 will become an equation when we compare it to something, assuming the comparison is to 0, then the solutions are as mentioned 1 and (1-) and these are the roots of the equation. The idea of ​​using radicals is to find an equation for the roots themselves using the coefficients (of the equation). But, as I recall, he proposed a solution to the problem in a mathematical article when he was only 20 years old, but upon repeated self-examination he discovered that a mistake had surfaced for which a different solution was required. In order to understand how brilliant and sharp Abel's mathematical mind was, it would be appropriate to compare it to an average guy nowadays who finished high school at the age of 18; Assuming that immediately after that he continues his studies for a bachelor's degree in mathematics, he is required to be able to deal with a main and fundamental mathematical problem that has occupied the best minds since the days of Tartellia and Cardano (about 250 years) and this after only two years in the academy.

Let's not forget that Abel was poor and the conditions in which he conducted his research were (even then) considered extremely difficult; So, despite the fact that the solution was not completely accurate, it would still be extremely difficult to find such a young person with such fantastic abilities. Following this mistake, the supervisor who was required to review the article advised him to focus on another important field that dealt with integrals. In the most simplistic way, it is said that an integral is a method of finding the area of ​​a certain region and constitutes, together with the differential, the two elements, apparently, the most important in the world of mathematics.

This recommendation was probably the most important in Abel's life and it did bear fruit; Immediately afterwards he was taken under the tutelage of Professor Hansteen from the Department of Astronomy at Christiana University. Hansteen supported him financially as well as morally and his wife even treated him as her own son. The year 1823 (when he was 21 years old) was significant for him, during which he published a number of fascinating articles in the aforementioned field. A year later he reached the peak of his life when he returned to work on the equation from the fifth degree and managed to prove that it cannot be solved using a radical. Again, although this is a complicated problem that this is not the place to explain, I can only say that only a few virtuous individuals are able to reach such a deep understanding of the world of mathematics. But he wanted his works to reach the desks of the great mathematicians in France and Germany, but he did not know the languages ​​spoken in these countries, so he studied them for two years until he knew them about Borin, something that helped him when he published a collection of articles in the French language with his personal money, which was also very little. Just to explain to the ear how bad his financial situation was even during the period in question, it is worth noting that Abel did not have a sufficient amount of money in his possession to describe his proofs in full and therefore he had to "shrink" them so that they all fit into a small number of pages.

During the next 4 years, Abel made a hopping trip between France and Germany in an attempt to be accepted into the local hegemony of mathematicians, but he received cold gestures from many of them, especially from the French whom he did not like, to say the least. In 1827 he returned to his home in Norway in poor health and even poorer after going into debt. When he returned to Christiana University, he was awarded a certain amount of money to get him back on his feet, but the heads of the institution made sure that this grant would be deducted from any future salary he would receive if he worked there. Although Abel was recognized in Norway as a mathematical genius, which was extremely rare at the time, not even the slightest effort was made to help him in a real way in his works that could bring honor and prestige to the country.

In order to raise some more money Abel started giving private lessons to school children while his wife was employed as a nanny in a family of Abel's friends. A slight improvement in his economic situation came when Professor Hansteen was sent to Siberia to study the magnetic force of the earth and Abel replaced him as a lecturer at the university and military academy.

In 1828 Abel returned to engage in the field he loved so much, which is finding a general solution for the use of radicals on equations - which would be proven a few years later by Everest visible (Galois).

But he also focused on the field called elliptic equations and worked together with another great mathematician named Jacobi; Legendre, who was a well-known French mathematician, commented that in his opinion these works place both of them in the first rank of the great minds of their time.

Comments of this kind helped Ebel to produce more and more mathematical studies whose importance is priceless, but at the same time his health deteriorated significantly and in fact it was the beginning of the end of the mathematical genius. Abel's colleague - the mathematician Carl (Crelle), did everything in his power to find him a suitable position in Germany and he did succeed in doing so, but it was too late and Abel died two days before Carl told him the happy news.

Abel's last days were spent in severe weakness and non-stop coughing, but this difficult situation did not prevent him from continuing to study mathematics, even though he could only get out of bed for a few minutes. But he used to tell about his severe poverty in the previous years and the kindness of Professor Hansteen's wife. The pain was especially unbearable on April 5th of the same year and in the morning of the next day, but it blew his soul and he is only 27 years old.

In 1830, the Parisian Academy awarded Yacovi Wabel (posthumously) an honorary award for their extraordinary work in its importance.

17 תגובות

  1. After I finished 3 units in high school I said let's try 5. I have no idea how people get through it. So for the writer of the article so that I can understand how smart in math Abel was, maybe try to describe it in mathematical units. I think at least 7 units.

  2. Well, I missed the key in the last sentence, so here is the ending:
    In induction, this is true for Kushi, Lagrange, Cantor, Taylor, Descartes, Newton, Leibniz, and many others, whose developments are currently studied by millions of students around the world in the first two years of their mathematics studies at university. It is therefore interesting why there are so few mathematicians who leave behind them mathematical developments of great significance as those listed above did, and why all the Alexandrovites of their kind (Gadi and his ilk) could not develop simple proofs as above. By the way, I would be very happy to receive a reference (REFERENCE) to other mathematical or scientific works carried out by Gadi Alexandrovich, since these works (the fruit of the development of an average student like Gadi) are certainly breakthroughs on any scale.

  3. Dear Gadi Alexandrovich,
    In your opinion, what Abel did (and after him Galois) was extremely simple since nowadays every first year student in mathematics is able to understand and reproduce the proof. That is, one should not be enthusiastic about the ability of Abel (or of Galua and the like). It was said that in the worst case scenario, humanity would have to remain relatively ignorant and wait only about 200 years until the appearance of someone of extremely mediocre ability like Gadi Alexandrovich, who would perform the aforementioned simple proof process in his first year at university, and provide humanity with the understanding that a solution cannot be found General for an equation with 5 vanishes. It goes without saying that the humble and poor Gadi Alexandrovich would have immediately given up any pretense of being called a mathematical genius or inventor or discoverer since his work could have been done by any first year mathematics student. In induction this is true for Kushi, Lagrange, Cantor, Taylor, Descartes, Newton, Leibniz, and many others, whose developments are now studied by millions of students in the first two years of

  4. Liran, please accept my words as constructive criticism that represents my opinion only.
    If you did this intentionally and consciously, then I will be the last to interfere with your writing. If this is the case if the reason for this decision is the dislike and fear of mathematics, then in my opinion this is a somewhat strange reason. In particular, when the article appears on a site such as the science where most people (I assume) have a certain interest in the field and much more complex news are published there (such as Dr. Moshe Nachmani's news) that gain a loyal readership (and I am among them).

    Each of us can open Wikipedia and check for ourselves how to solve a third and fourth degree equation. If so, I think it would add a lot if some explanation were added, even if in simple language and without equations, explaining the meaning of such revelations and the work involved so that even a person who is not proficient in mathematics (and perhaps also afraid of it) could confess and fully experience the servitude of the man and the depth inherent in it.

  5. This is nothing compared to what they did to Nils Holgersson!!

    Which they turned into these viking dwarfs.

  6. If all Liran meant to say is that in order to reach the achievements of Abel one needs such an understanding - great. I got the impression that he was dragging it in the direction of Fermat's last theorem, meaning that the proof itself is so difficult that you need a deep understanding of mathematics to read it.

    If this is not the intention, then my complaint is directed only to the unclear wording (and to the fact that, as usual, the really interesting details are avoided, but we have already complained about it here).

  7. kid,
    What's the problem with going up 40 floors on foot? I can even go up to the 50th floor, with an elevator...
    That's about what you said 🙂
    But he began to pave the path to understanding the solution and the problem, and did not follow the path that others followed. Likewise, for example, the theory of relativity, or anything else. Understanding it is less problematic than conceiving it.

  8. Liran, do you think that saying about the unsolvability of the fifth degree equation with radicals that "only a few virtuous individuals are able to reach such a deep understanding of the world of mathematics" is what will encourage interest? Is this what will make those who don't like, like? Telling them they have no chance of understanding it?

  9. Answers:

    XNUMX - details about such mathematical tools can be found in any academic library for mathematics or physics.
    Expanding on them is not of interest for the purpose of writing this article. I always try to explain (in talkbacks it should be noted) that these articles are supposed to touch the common man, that the connection between him and mathematics is purely coincidental, which usually causes aversion to this field. Before I started writing, I decided that I would completely exclude anything related to complicated mathematical equations or explanations, since such a thing would immediately cause the reading to be neglected.
    I don't write to teach math but to make math like it for those who don't like it.
    One of my main goals is that following what I've written people will actually take that step towards an interest in mathematics; If following these things you think that radicals are something fascinating, then two things:
    First of all, I did my part and I'm happy about it, second thing is as I mentioned - in every mathematical library there are large and detailed books that can explain things much better than I can.

    Successfully

  10. Ziv, I didn't ask him to elaborate (it's impossible in such an article) but not to scare. If there is one thing that really saddens me, it is the "impossible" aura that sometimes likes to attach to mathematics.

  11. Thanks Michael, but I'm afraid Wikipedia is not new to me or anyone else here on the site. And those who want to delve into the solution of equations of the fifth degree or the life of Abel also knew to turn to the library.
    If so, I still think it would be good if things were more detailed and explained in the article itself, if only for the sake of "plot perfection". I also missed this a little in the article about Tartalia.

  12. kid,

    Not all readers are undergraduate students in mathematics.
    Like me.. the article is very interesting and I learned a lot from it... you don't always need to detail everything..

    Happy holiday!

  13. I would be happy if you could elaborate and explain more about radicals and other mathematical elements mentioned in the article. Instead of solving them with a one-line explanation or a simple analogy.

    I think this would have added more volume to the article, especially for those people among us whose knowledge of mathematics is limited to general introductory courses.

  14. "A year later he reached the peak of his life when he returned to work on the equation from the fifth degree and succeeded in proving that it cannot be solved using a radical. Again, although it is a complicated problem that this is not the place to explain, I can only say that only a few virtuous individuals are able to reach such a profound understanding of the world of mathematics ."

    You exaggerate. Every bachelor's degree student in mathematics these days is able to understand the problem and its solution, and in a greater depth than Abel himself reached (the depth that Galua theory provides). It doesn't detract from the genius of Abel (who was ahead of Galois and invented everything more or less from scratch) or the beauty of it all, but you shouldn't equate everything with a mystical and impossible aura.

Leave a Reply

Email will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismat to prevent spam messages. Click here to learn how your response data is processed.