Comprehensive coverage

The TMT: The ultra-orthodox choose poverty on purpose

A recent analysis of the employment characteristics of the ultra-Orthodox population conducted by the Research and Economic Administration at the Ministry of the Ministry of Education and Culture shows that the rate of participants in the workforce is slightly more than half that of the secular and they also earn half as much. However, they allow themselves to differ from working together with secularists * The number of IDF evaders has doubled in 14 years

The senior representative of the ultra-Orthodox in the Knesset, Yaakov Litzman, Deputy Minister of Health (2010) ironically represents Israel at the OCED conference
The senior representative of the ultra-Orthodox in the Knesset, Yaakov Litzman, Deputy Minister of Health (2010) ironically represents Israel at the OCED conference

The above article is taken from the press release of the Ministry of Public Security - 3/5/2010

A country haunted by demons XNUMX - Huldai is right, but it's not enough just to complain

The general employment rate - of the ultra-orthodox sector as a whole (women and men) is 43.2%. The participation rate in the workforce was 48.5% compared to the participation rate among the secular population which was 79%. This is according to the analysis of the employment characteristics of the ultra-Orthodox population in 2009-2010, published yesterday by the Research and Economics Administration of the Ministry of Education and Culture.
The research shows that the employment rate of ultra-Orthodox men - despite positive trends in recent years, the employment rates of this public remain very low. On a multi-year average, the employment rate of ultra-Orthodox men was only 37%[1] and is significantly lower than the employment rate of secular-traditional men, which is approximately 80%. The rate of unemployed ultra-orthodox men[2] was 10% (compared to 7% among secular-traditional men). The employment rate of ultra-Orthodox women - also the employment rate of ultra-orthodox women which was 49% is significantly lower than the employment rate of secular women (70%). The unemployment rate among this public was 13% compared to 9% among the secular-traditional public.

Below are selected data from the report

Employment by branches and working hours

  • Work in the public sector - a high percentage of those employed in the ultra-Orthodox public work in public services, and especially in the field of teaching and education within the ultra-Orthodox sector internally, the phenomenon is particularly prevalent among women (72% of those employed in these sectors and 56% are employed in the education sector only) of whom about 70% work in jobs Partiality. 45% of ultra-Orthodox men are employed in these industries (compared to 43.5% of women and only 20% of ultra-Orthodox men)
  • Work in industry - only 13.7% of ultra-Orthodox men are employed in industry compared to 22.3% of secular men. 4.8% of ultra-Orthodox women are employed in these industries compared to 11% of secular-traditional women
  • Work opinions - Also, only 31% of ultra-Orthodox women work full-time (35 hours per week or more) compared to 71% of ultra-Orthodox men who work full-time

Work for a secular employer

  • Only about 26.5% of ultra-Orthodox employees in the business sector are employed by a secular employer. It was also found that only 8% of businesses in the business sector in Israel employ ultra-Orthodox workers.

Wages, income and poverty

  • As a result of the factors mentioned above, large disparities in wage levels and income levels between ultra-Orthodox and non-Orthodox have arisen in Israel: (a) The average level of income for an ultra-Orthodox household is about 6,100 NIS per month and is half the average monthly income for a non-Orthodox household of about 12,000 NIS (b) The average monthly salary of an ultra-orthodox woman was only about 3,700 NIS compared to the average monthly salary of a secular woman, which was 5,700 NIS (54% wage gap). The average monthly salary of an ultra-orthodox man was about NIS 6,100, while the average monthly salary of a secular man was NIS 8,950 (46% wage gap).
  • About 56% of the ultra-orthodox are defined as poor[3]. Also, despite the fact that the proportion of the ultra-Orthodox population varies between 8-9% of the total population in Israel, the ultra-Orthodox make up about 19% of all the poor in Israel.

The attitudes of the ultra-Orthodox public and the attitudes of non-Orthodox employers

The attitudes of the ultra-Orthodox public in relation to the labor market

  • Surveys show that 65% of ultra-Orthodox job seekers (70% of women and 60% of men)[4] state that they are not interested in working in mixed businesses where there is no separation between the sexes or where most of the employees are not ultra-Orthodox

Employers' positions regarding the employment of ultra-Orthodox workers

  • 95% of employers in the business sector estimate that since there is no separation between women and men in workplaces, it will be difficult to integrate ultra-Orthodox workers. On the other hand, about 90% of employers estimate that most of the ultra-Orthodox have appropriate skills for various positions in the business

demography

  • The size of the population - The size of the ultra-Orthodox population reaches about 650 thousand people, which make up between 8%-9% of the total population in Israel. The ultra-Orthodox population of working age (20-64) is counted
  • About 235 thousand people (of which about 120 thousand are men). This population grows at an average annual rate of 7%, this is due to the high natural reproduction of this diverse population.
  • The ultra-Orthodox population according to currents - estimates are that the ultra-Orthodox population in Israel is divided according to currents as follows: 33% of the ultra-Orthodox belong to the Lithuanian stream, 29% of the ultra-Orthodox belong to the Hasidic stream, 21% belong to the Spanish stream, 10% are unidentified ultra-Orthodox and 7% are ultra-nationalists
  • The population in the "Torah Art" order - today there are about 55 ultra-orthodox men in this order, and in 2008 they made up about 11% of the enlistment year for the Tehel, while in 1994 they made up only about 6% of the enlistment year. –
  • The ultra-Orthodox students in the elementary education system - the students of the ultra-orthodox education systems (in its various shades and at different ages) made up in 2009 about 15.5% of all students in the elementary education system in Israel and their proportion increased more than 2 times in the last decade in elementary education.
  • Trends in demographic growth - if the trend of demographic growth that characterized the last decade continues, the ultra-Orthodox population of the main working ages (25-64) in 2030 will make up about 17% of this age group. Today this population constitutes only about 6% of the working age group.

Education and computer use

  • Years of study and high school diploma - ultra-Orthodox men study for many years (14.8 years on average), most of them in different Torah settings. However, only 9.5% of them have a matriculation certificate or an academic degree.
  • Knowledge of English - about 40% of ultra-Orthodox men do not know English at all and 41% of them know English at an intermediate level or below (compared to 17% of secular men who do not know English at all)
  • 42% of ultra-Orthodox women have a high school diploma, mainly in the field of teaching and education. Only 11.5% of ultra-orthodox women have an academic degree. 21% of them do not know English at all (about 49% of them know English at an intermediate level or below and a third know English at a good level)
  • Computers and Internet - 40% of ultra-Orthodox households have a computer at home, but only about a quarter of them (24.6%) of the households that have a computer are connected to the Internet.
Table 1: Characteristics of education, employment and income of the ultra-orthodox sector compared to the secular sector, by gender in the ages 20-64 (in percentages of the total). Source: Ministry of the Orthodox Church, May 2010
Table 1: Characteristics of education, employment and income of the ultra-orthodox sector compared to the secular sector, by gender in the ages 20-64 (in percentages of the total). Source: Ministry of the Orthodox Church, May 2010

[1] Average for the years 2002-2007 for ages 20-64
[2] Those who were looking for work from the workforce
[3] Source: Research Administration at the National Insurance Institute
[4] Mapping ultra-orthodox employers and their attitudes (2009) Research and Economics Administration, Ministry of the Ministry of Education

15 תגובות

  1. Continue to comment 12.
    Of course you need to enter the Bnei Barak municipality profile and scroll to page 13 there.

  2. I am a long time reader and I rarely comment…
    Why did I respond? When I see stupid comments like: "They have insanely high fertility anyway - so we'll get out of the country" "Everyone is going to be ultra-Orthodox and Arab here - I'm going" These are comments from weak and lazy people who probably won't be able to get American citizenship...
    what is the solution I don't know exactly, I'm a young man, but what's certain is that we need to strive in the direction of separating religion and state, extreme cuts in allowances (including a reduction in transfer payments), cuts in the shepherds' stipend, and endless other examples.
    Now say, you are anti-Semitic, you want there to be less children for the ultra-Orthodox!!! So the answer is that I really want the ultra-Orthodox to have fewer children, to return to the fertility patterns of the past, today an ultra-Orthodox woman is at an all-time high in terms of birthrates, and all this because it pays to have lots of children.
    http://www.cbs.gov.il/census/?MIval=%2Fcensus%2Fpnimi_sub2_profiles.html&id_topic=11&id_subtopic=1&id_subtopic2=4&Semel_Maamad_Mi=0&Semel=6100
    In the above link (on page 13) you will see that the downward trend in the ultra-orthodox birth rate has been halted and not only has it been halted, but has increased sharply.
    I know families who simply said "for every child born, we feel richer" I'm not lying, I grew up in a very religious-Orthodox society (I'm secular).
    And regarding the article, I don't think it's true a natural increase of 7% per year, it just doesn't make sense.
    If you check the Gidnal rate of votes that the "Torah Judaism" party received between 92 and the last election, you will reach 3.4% per year (it's actually quite a bit higher, because there was a sort of "voter boycott" in Zeyr Anfin).
    It's just sad that people are leaving Israel.

  3. 40.5% of income in the economy belongs to the top two deciles.
    When the population size of the two upper deciles is a few percent.
    You have to calculate with statistical tools to get the real average.
    And not just to average to get numbers that are more suitable for them.

  4. Host of the Universe:

    If they invade, no one wants a house infested with leeches and vampires.

  5. Gil, I did not understand why the average salary is not average. The top deciles do not earn a "huge fortune". In fact, it can be said that Israel is the only country in the world where the top decile buys at a discount center...
    Emigrating abroad as you recommended, is a stupid solution in which you run away from your home and are allowed to invade your home. You have to fight for the house, for the education of your children and their future.
    By the way, another problem that does not come to awareness is the unfortunate fact that many ultra-Orthodox women who are involved in teaching, flow into secular education, where they cause additional damage to the one we have already discussed.

  6. I agree with the great majority of what is said in the articles, it's just that your definition of science is a bit too big sometimes, if you can put it that way, and in the articles that do deal with science, sometimes there is too much exaggeration and personal opinion.

  7. The average salary is not exactly average, it is rather the "fabricated salary"
    There are the top deciles which are a small percentage of the population that earns a huge fortune.
    When the majority of the population in Israel earns a salary that aspires to the minimum wage.

    As for the ultra-Orthodox, there is a saying that says if you can't fight them, join them.
    On average, they give birth to 6 times more children than the seculars.
    In such a situation you don't have much room for movement, the maximum is to emigrate abroad if you are not feeling well.

  8. The site is designed to promote science.
    One of the ways to promote science is to burn the fires.
    What is not clear here - gentlemen 2 and 3?

  9. For those who call themselves 4
    The first time I hear a claim that articles about the environment are not scientific articles. After all, global warming is the biggest scientific problem facing the human race, and it has many consequences such as a decrease in the variety of species, the spread of deserts and many things that science has to deal with in order to allow humans to live. As for the ultra-Orthodox - part of the site's concept is also the topic of scientific skepticism. The problem would not exist if the ultra-Orthodox would only take care of themselves and not spoil the education of the other children and increase their ignorance.

  10. Nice article, but it's annoying that it has nothing to do with science.
    You are just taking advantage of the fact that you have readers who will listen to you.
    This time it's politics, sometimes it's trips and nature, you're taking advantage of the fact that probably readers who are interested in science have certain right-wing opinions and a certain level of circumstantial care, if you call it that.
    In short, as long as you read the Hidan website, stay only with the articles related to science because the environment does not bother me and I prefer to read policy and political news in places that are supposed to deal with it.

Leave a Reply

Email will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismat to prevent spam messages. Click here to learn how your response data is processed.