They too were convinced that mysticism was nonsense, that dreams were just dreams, that ancestors were blindfolds, that there was no connection between fate and astrology, that a seance was a ritual that was all fraud and that every phenomenon had a simple rational explanation. But then something strange happened to them. Very strange. Scientists, a rabbi, and a spiritual guide respond to personal stories about dreams, astrology, and seances.
By: Eilat Baram and Orly Gal
You don't need a prophetic sense to know the following details about you: You are curious, strive for perfection, critical, have an aesthetic sense and love to help. You once had a significant relationship from which you came out hurt, you like to do things with your hands, you had difficulties in life but managed to overcome them thanks to your special character and the support you received from a close soul. After the difficult days you will go through, a good period will come, and it is very possible that you will enjoy a trip in the coming year (perhaps already during the Passover holiday).
These kinds of comprehensive character predictions and analyses are easy to make and very easy to explain, but there are events that are difficult to dismiss with cynical contempt. It is doubly difficult when the storyteller is a rational and trustworthy person, free from mystical tendencies in his private life. In such cases, even when looking for explanations that do not involve the grace of heaven, pendulums, stars and cards, they are not always obvious. Judge for yourself.
Fathers (Kabbalists and healers)
"I came to Rabbi Yosef Shriki from Netivot as part of a newspaper article that was not directly or indirectly related to his abilities as a kabbalist and a baba. His brother, who serves as his driver, told me before I entered the meeting: 'You will tremble.' Not as a threat, but more as a kind of promise. I did not take it seriously. I entered, put the tape on the table, and before I started recording, Rabbi Shriki asked me for my name and my mother's name. Then he diagnosed two medical problems that my mother suffers from, and pointed out their exact location in the body. For one problem, she was treated by doctors and Shriki said that the treatment was in vain, and he was right. The second problem he diagnosed, nerve sensitivity in the shoulder area, has been bothering her for many years, but she has never complained about it and has not had it treated.
"I started to tremble inside. Within a few minutes I was filled with awe, so much so that I didn't have the courage to ask him to stop talking. It's scary. He couldn't have known the things he said even if he had employed a talented and diligent team of investigators from the moment he knew I was going to come to him, because some of them are not written in the documents and there are also things he predicted. Ostensibly, he had an interest in impressing me so that it would affect the tone of the article, but I tried very hard not to let that happen. I suppose if I ever get in trouble, I'll go back to him for advice."
(Y', journalist)
Rabbi Meir Azri, a Reform rabbi from the Center for Progressive Judaism, is appalled. "In the Judaism that has developed in Israel in recent years, gangs of tricksters have emerged, who call themselves rabbis, and they exploit ignorance and weakness and offer a variety of spells and rituals," he warns. "The Judaism that I know is far from witchcraft and mysticism and casts a heavy stain on sorcerers and miracle workers of all kinds, who reduce Judaism to prostitution and give rise to ancestor worship. The problem is that the enlightened public is not shattering the myths, and is not giving the innocent the tools to break this industry."
Prof. Yoel Donhin, a senior physician at Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital, is happy to dispel the myth. "I don't know how to define nerve sensitivity in the shoulders, but in exchange for a suitable Baba suit, an assistant who will mentally prepare people for the fateful meeting, and a modest sum, I am willing to tell a hundred people what illness their relatives have. I will tell one person that his father suffers from back pain when he bends over, and that his grandfather suffers from difficulty urinating, so he should go to the doctor before it's too late. I assume that my chances of success will be around fifty percent, which will consist of wild guesswork plus healthy intuition."
"There are a lot of people who talk about receiving information in an unexplained way," says Dr. David Green, an expert in clinical psychology and director of the Green Institute for Advanced Psychology, "but all the evidence comes from people who believe. It's mostly coincidence, but the common explanation is telepathy or very strong intuitions."
Prof. Shneur Lipson, a physicist and chemist at the Weizmann Institute, is much less forgiving: "I have a choice between imagination and lying, but how can I say without being there? It could be that the rabbi sent spies or hypnotized Y., or Y. didn't understand what was said because of the excitement. We can only speculate about what happened there, but the hypotheses must be tested scientifically."
Prof. Kedma Bar Eli, from the School of Chemistry at Tel Aviv University, is willing to try his hand: "I find it hard to believe that the aforementioned Shiriki employs legions of investigators, but since he had a clear interest in impressing the journalist, it is possible. In any case, there is no doubt that Shiriki succeeded. The journalist was so impressed by the matter that he began to tremble and claimed that if he was ever in trouble, he would come back to him."
If you were him, wouldn't you be impressed?
"Of course I would be impressed, but the magician Lior Manor is also impressive, and I wouldn't go to consult with him on personal matters."
Zohar Lev Naor, who prefers to be called Tara, a spiritual guide from Rishon LeZion, is completely clear about what happened there.
"The nervous system works on electricity. When too much current passes through it, there is tremors, loss of consciousness, and even a short, what is called a stroke. This kabbalah works with high electrical frequencies, because people who do spiritual work practice their systems. When a person enters an electric field that is more charged than usual, the natural reaction is tremors. The law of resonance states that if you put two loudspeakers for the same note in two separate rooms and strike one of them, the other will also begin to vibrate without being touched. According to these laws, which are completely physical, when Y. thinks of his mother, the rabbi can tune himself to the right frequency and receive the thought."
Dr. Yair Lampel, deputy director of the neurology department at Wolfson Hospital, agrees only with the first sentence: "The brain really works with the help of electrical waves, which can be detected in an EEG test, but a higher frequency is not better. Above or below the number of brain waves per unit of time, this is an abnormal condition. You see things like this in people who take certain medications. A stroke is a condition in which part of the brain is destroyed by a blockage or bursting of a blood vessel; it is not the result of overactivity. There is no evidence of a person's ability to dress up in another person's brain waves, or change their EEG. It doesn't make sense, and in any case, a person's brain waves don't affect people around them, just like my EKG doesn't affect another person's heart activity."
The hero of the story, Rabbi Yosef Shriki, is not interested in being interviewed. Moti Shriki, his son and manager of his office, explains why: "What does the rabbi say? 'Evil thoughts are in the heart of a man, and my advice will stand.' Evil is an acronym for radio, newspaper, video, television. Faith passes from ear to ear. I haven't had an appointment to give to people for two months."
Dreams
"Seven months before my brother was killed in Lebanon, I dreamed that he was walking past me when he was shot in the head. I don't attach importance to dreams, so I ignored that dream too, but it came back all that week. My brother also had the feeling that he was going to die. He always told me that he would die young. We even made a list of names, who to notify when he was killed. He told me to go to his funeral like I was going to his wedding. I wasn't surprised when they came and told us that he had been killed. A month before the disaster, he started saying goodbye to everyone around him, his parents, rabbis and friends. I didn't go to investigate and didn't look for explanations, because it wouldn't change anything."
(Tamar Har Shoshen, sister of the late Yoav, who was killed in Lebanon)
"I was a combat soldier in Lebanon, and I thought about my death more than once," Rabbi Azari tries to explain. "Every time I went up there, I was very scared, and sometimes I said goodbye to people. Once I even left a farewell letter to my wife. When parents send a child to the army, they are scared. Doesn't a businessman who invests all his fortune in the stock market sometimes dream that the stock market is falling? Such a dream is natural."
Prof. Avi Ori, a specialist in rehabilitation medicine at Tel Aviv University, thinks that such a dream is not only natural, but also expected: "Lebanon has been a place prone to disaster for many years. People are afraid, think and talk about it when they are fully awake, and some of the fears and concerns also appear in sleep. Furthermore, I don't know whether the dream was reported before or after the brother was killed. People have a tendency to cut corners after things happen."
"It happened shortly after Benny Dolev passed away. That day I was supposed to be at work at 12, so I allowed myself to sleep in late. I woke up at 8:30 in the morning and went back to sleep. Then I dreamed that Gal, my daughter, was driving a car. It seemed a little strange to me, because she was too young to drive a car, but she drove the car into an intersection, got stuck in a tree and died. The rest of the dream I walked around the car and shouted to God: 'You took Dolev from me, don't take Gal from me!'
"I woke up at nine thirty feeling bad, but I told myself that Gal was at school at such an hour, and I shouldn't attach importance to the dream. At ten she called me from the hospital and said that she had been in an accident with her motorcycle, but everything was fine. I believe that she was supposed to die in the accident, and that my prayers saved her."
(C, family doctor)
Prof. Dov Lichtenberg, deputy dean of the Faculty of Medicine at Tel Aviv University, refuses to be impressed: "How many women have dreamed that something happened to their child, but nothing happened to him and therefore they have nothing to tell? I know a lot of people who have dreamed terrible and horrible things that didn't happen. It's a coincidence. It's like the story about the man who went to the doctor and was immediately given two medications: for the prostate and for diabetes, because there was a urine stain on his pants and flies on him. So he happened to score a goal. In a lot of other cases, it didn't make it into a story."
"A person interprets dreams in light of the events that followed," adds Dr. Green. "We dream every night and most dreams are not connected to anything. It is not certain that what J thinks she dreamed is really what she dreamed, because people tend to add and correct according to what happened."
Dr. Yoav Ben-Dov, a lecturer in physics and philosophy of science at the Institute for the History of Science at Tel Aviv University (and a tarot reader in his free time), is not willing to ignore the phenomenon:
"This thing is inherently elusive, because it is related to emotional layers and exists on the fringes of reality. It is not something that goes beyond science or contradicts it, but rather happens on other levels. The only thing I can say is that it happens to me and to people I know, but it happens in life and not in science."
Zvi Yanai, former director general of the Ministry of Science, sees no value in the discussion, and explains why: "Let's assume someone appears and says that four hours before an earthquake, the angel Daniel appeared to her in a dream and told her to pack up and run. Let's assume she's not a liar and truly believes that she had such a dream. There's no way to prove that it's not true. That's why you shouldn't argue with personal experiences. Science always comes out badly from it. They will always remain a personal experience that doesn't indicate anything."
birds
"My mother died 24 years ago and was buried in a small cemetery in the village of Samir at the foot of Mount Carmel. 12 years after her death, my wife's mother died and was buried two hundred meters away from her. One day I visited the cemetery. A dove sat peacefully on my mother's tombstone. A few minutes later, I started walking toward my mother-in-law's grave, and the dove hovered above me and accompanied me the entire way. Of all the tombstones, it finally rested on the grave of my wife's mother. When I returned home, I immediately called my friend who is interested in mysticism, and he interrupted me in the middle of the story and told me that this scenario is familiar in literature dealing with reincarnation, and that the spirit of one of the two women is in this bird."
(Dudo Dotan, entertainer)
The birds, it turns out, are not limited to the Dotan family. A few weeks before the article was published in January 1999, Yair Lapid told a similar family anecdote on his show. "I come from a devout secular family," he said, "whose only exception was Grandma Helen, who had something inexplicable about her." Lapid later described how on the day the grandmother died, her daughter, the writer Shulamit Lapid, went home to prepare food for seven. A small bird flew in through the window and sat on the refrigerator. Shulamit Lapid, Yair said, had a feeling that it was Grandma Helen coming to say hello, so after about fifteen minutes she called her father and told him that a small bird with a long black-and-blue beak had visited the house. "A bird with a yellow spot on its chest?" the father asked. "Yes," she replied, "how do you know?" "Because it's sitting on my refrigerator right now," he replied.
Shulamit Lapid was not really happy to comment on the matter: "This is a one-off and marginal case. I don't believe in irrationality, I don't believe in mysticism, and I don't want to contribute to dealing with it. To get a rational explanation, you need Zvi Yanai to explain mathematically what the chances are of meeting two identical birds like this in Tel Aviv."
"Many coincidences can be explained mathematically," Yanai faithfully plays his part. "You can check whether an event could or could not have happened statistically. But there are people who don't believe in coincidences, for whom everything happens because there is a reason. To that I say: The righteous will live by faith."
"The explanation in such cases is that there is no explanation," says Dr. Ben-Dov. "We will never know whether it is a coincidence or a significant event. The meaning that a person gives to the things he experiences is not related to the laws of nature but to the human context. That is why these events are powerful. They have no scientific existence, because it is not something that exists outside of the human context."
astrology
"At the beginning of the year, I went through a very difficult time. A long relationship, which I was sure would lead to marriage, ended. After the breakup, I was in a desperate state, and my mother suggested that I go to consult with an astrologer from Hadera, whom she had visited once. I went. She is a new immigrant from Russia, a musician who studied psychology and biology. I have always believed in astrology, but I have never known anyone who could detail things in such a way. She made a map for me and my ex-boyfriend and told me that I came to this life with baggage from another life, that I was a doctor in one of the world wars and because of my medical negligence someone died, and that my calling here is to help heal. I was already involved in alternative medicine at that time. She said that I was involved in dance or music, and I really did dance for 12 years. She told me that I had been in a car accident and mentioned the correct year and month. She mentioned specific gynecological problems that I suffer from and said that my father had a heart attack and the month and year were correct. She can tell you what food you like and the color of your eyes. Your mother.
"According to my boyfriend's astrological chart, she knew that his father was abroad, and that he was forbidden to return to Israel due to criminal involvement. She said that they were looking for him abroad as well, and I didn't even know that at the time. It wasn't until two or three months later that I realized it was true."
(A, medical secretary)
"I suspect that the person himself blurts out things and half-things when he sits with an astrologer," says Prof. Bar Eli, "things along the lines of 'My mother looks a lot like me.' If you have blue eyes, then your mother probably does too. This case is simpler: her mother was there, she obviously knows what color her eyes are."
How did she know about her past as a dancer?
"Perhaps because of her Russian appearance, she is believed to have probably danced for many years."
Prof. Bar Eli unintentionally demonstrated considerable mystical abilities. The astrologer, who chose to remain anonymous, speaks only Russian, a language that A., it turns out, knows about her birth. "From the time of birth, with an accuracy of up to two minutes, and from the place of birth, you can deduce things about a person's character," says the astrologer. "In the astrological map of Israel, for example, you could see the helicopter disaster. The map showed a serious military situation at the time. I predict a very difficult year. People are unhappy, and if the economy doesn't improve, we will be poor. This is very bad. We need to turn to a capitalist economy, not a socialist one. There is a lot to do, and we will get to that sooner or later. It is better to follow the signs."
Prof. Lipson: "With the help of physics and astronomy, it is not possible to explain a conjunction of stars that affects our personal destiny. It does not work out with chemistry and biology either. Psychology remains. At a conference of the Academy of Sciences in New York called 'Escape from Science and Common Sense,' one of the lecturers explained that in the learning process there is a stage of magical thinking, which is similar to scientific thinking, but lacks control. It has no importance for observations, experimentation, or adjustment to other facts. It is a primitive way of thinking.
"Before the '81 elections, when Yaakov Meridor announced that he would be able to light up all of Ramat Gan with a single light bulb, a reporter called me and asked my opinion. I told him that it was nonsense and pessimism. He asked me how I, as a scientist, could make a judgment without delving into the facts. I told him that if Meridor is right, then Einstein is wrong, and if Einstein is right, Meridor is wrong. And when I have to decide which of the two to believe, the decision is quite easy. I know the laws of physics well enough to say that some things are completely absurd, and the best example of this is astrology. What cannot happen – did not happen."
Zvi Yanai doesn't have the strength to get angry: "The number of people who believe in irrational phenomena is even greater than it was at the beginning of the century. Scientific methods simply don't answer irrational questions. As long as astrologer Miriam Benyamini is a sought-after interviewee and on Rosh Hashanah astrologers are invited to give predictions like 'there will probably be peace with Syria,' there's no point in fighting the phenomenon."
telepathy
"Two months ago I went to a consultation with a reader in Siddur. She knew the names of all my family members, including grandparents. But what surprised me the most was when she mentioned a strange name that I didn't recognize, and said that the man with that name was connected to my father in the past and wanted to harm him. I wrote down the name, which had no meaning to me, and when I got home I asked my father if he knew that strange name. Dad was shocked. It was the nickname of his business partner five years ago. In my opinion, there was no way she could have gotten that name, because it's not an official name and it doesn't appear in the records."
(A, research assistant in the field of pharmacology)
"These people are exploiting innocence," protests Rabbi Meir Azari. "Opening with a siddur sounds much better than opening cards or playing with a needle. If God is speaking to her, I wonder which siddur he prefers, Ashkenazi or Sephardi."
Dr. Green is still looking for an explanation: "The girl probably knows her father's problems subconsciously. If the reader of the Siddur has the mystical qualities attributed to her, and she certainly doesn't, she could read any book and receive the signs from the Higher Power, because telepathy also occurs unconsciously. The Higher Power would also guide her with a chipotle or a phone book. The Siddur only adds a mystical touch."
Tara agrees: "There is no difference whether you read in a siddur or a phone book, because it is just a way for the reader in the siddur to connect to the client's frequencies. The name itself was not written in the siddur, but while reading it, it appeared within it as knowledge. Thought is very powerful, and from it you can also deduce things that the person who thinks it himself does not know."
"About twenty years ago, when I was 16, my father was killed or committed suicide. The day before his death, a senior officer from his job came to our house and there was terrible shouting. The next day he was supposed to have a meeting with that senior officer. Before the meeting, he told his clerk that he was going to the bathroom, and he didn't come back. The senior officer went to the bathroom and found him lying in a pool of blood with a gunshot wound to the head. It was not clear exactly how he died. He didn't leave a suicide note, and the signs did not unequivocally point to suicide, so to this day we don't know exactly what happened.
A few weeks ago I met with a caller named Lord Aristotle. He knew the name of my father's boss at work, the name of my ex-husband, the name of my grandmother. Regarding my father's death, he saw that there had been a big fight, and that my father felt that if he continued in his job he would be contributing to corruption and bringing disgrace to himself and his family, so he committed suicide."
(Hila Livni, bureau manager)
It was with regard to us that Lord Aristotle had serious communication problems: "'Ha'ir' newspaper? Yes, I remember you. During the time when Gal Ochovsky was editor, you wrote an article about me that ruined my career. Ari Shamai came to me, sat at my house, and I talk to him like a friend. It took me five years to restore the business, I lost all my clients because of that article. So I don't want to hear from you anymore. Have a nice day."
And he was right, it really was a pleasant day, but Prof. Yoel Donkhin does not attribute this to Aristotle: "The fortune tellers, who know how to tell the audience, but never for free, what will happen in the future, are not for some reason endowed with the power to predict what their own future will be. I have also never heard the wonderful story of a foolish follower who paid the best of his money and tells of the charlatan's helplessness, for example, about how he told him that his mother suffered from hemorrhoids and now he has been an orphan for thirty years."
"If he had the strength, he could win the lottery," says Rabbi Azari, who has sound financial sense, "but he will probably say that his great righteousness prevents him from using his strength in this way. Many times it is not difficult to see people's problems, and many times intuition is enough."
Death
"The first seance I attended was on an annual trip in 12th grade. The first spirit we summoned was called Mazal Hess. We asked if she could give a physical sign of her existence, she said yes and spelled the word 'photograph' on the board. We asked which photo, and she said 7. After the trip, we developed the film. Photo number seven came out strange, burnt with strange clouds, even though all the other photos were fine.
"In that seance, I conjured up the spirit of my father, who had died a year earlier from lung cancer. We asked him what he had died of, and the glass moved to 'drug,' which is cigarettes. I asked if he had anything to say, and he said 'sorry.' I was tense and shocked that the glass had moved at all. I cried and my friends calmed me down. In my opinion, there's no way anyone pushed the glass. We're good friends, and if one of us was working on the others, it would have been revealed over the years. Over time, we discovered that without concentration and fear, conversations with spirits become nonsense very quickly."
(Persian cedar, physicist)
"In our hearts we believe that there is something beyond this life," says Prof. Bar Eli, "and science simply takes that belief one step further. None of us would dare take our deceased relative and feed him to lions on safari. Most people would be horrified by the mere idea, even though rationally it is absurd."
But that doesn't explain how the cup moves.
"Everyone wants the glass to move to 'yes' when they ask if there's a spirit around, otherwise it wouldn't be interesting. If the glass moves out of the general excitement, everyone tends to join in. All the members of the séance knew that his father had passed away, and everyone also knew what. Cigarettes, cancer, drugs, they all start with a "S", so that's likely where the glass would move. I have a feeling that if no one had moved it, the glass wouldn't have moved."
Tara does not doubt the credibility of the story: "There was probably something unresolved between Erez and his father, and this was an opportunity to release the baggage. Often, death processes are not completely perfect, and particles of emotions remain here as unfinished things. This is what appears in seances. Fear is a catalyst. This is the principle: because the participants are afraid, they attract things to them that will scare them. Therefore, when they are not afraid, nothing happens."
So why when they are not afraid do not come happy spirits?
"There are no such spirits at the level of a séance."
Rabbi Azri is not impressed: "Raising the dead to play a game is somehow okay, but there are people who do seances to get direction in life, and I don't accept that. I participated in all kinds of such experiments in my youth. I wasn't convinced."
Prof. Lipson is also not convinced: "I think if they had put video cameras in the séance, they would have discovered that nothing happened there. This story reminds me of an excerpt from Huxley's 'Science of Life': The British Crown Prince traveled with his entourage to India, and there they met a fakir who performed a miracle: he cut his assistant into pieces and then brought him back to life. Everyone saw it. Almost as miraculous as the séance. Except that the Crown Prince was filming the entire event, and when he developed the photos, there was nothing of any of these sights. It was all in his imagination. I don't know how everyone imagined the same thing, but for once these are facts."
"My husband passed away seven years ago. After his passing, I left our shared apartment and returned there six months later. When I was tidying up the house, I found two international licenses. I opened his and said to myself out loud: 'Oh, Zvika.' At that second, a light bulb exploded above me. Another time, I was returning with a friend in a taxi, and the second I mentioned Zvika's name, the little lamp above us went out.
"At one gathering with friends we talked about reincarnation, and everyone laughed at my beliefs.
When we left the house together, a whole row of street lamps went out at the same second. There's also a funny story: One morning I woke up and felt the whole bed move. I turned on the light and saw that a picture had fallen to the floor. The first thing I did was open the window, because I thought Zvika's soul was trapped in the room and trying to find a way out. Then they announced on the news that there had been an earthquake."
(Hani Nahmias, actress)
"In these cases, truth is in the eye of the beholder," sighs Dr. Green in despair. "Only people who are interested in receiving reinforcements and looking for direction find explanations and interpretations from here to there for simple and meaningless events."
Rabbi Meir Azri actually understands Nachmias's heart: "Many experience these feelings. My father passed away 13 years ago and I too saw him in dreams. Every person talks and communicates with their loved ones who have passed away. This is legitimate."
"Zvika's soul came back as energy," Tara explains. "Energy never runs out. In my opinion, he came to say hello."
Why give hints, and not write hello on a note that will be clear?
"It is forbidden to interfere. You are only allowed to give a hint."
Prof. Donhin does not believe in clues: "Only to the naive who attach importance to the voices coming from the omen, to the cards mixed with coffee grounds and placed on a pendulum located on the life lines of the palm, all these stories will please. They will continue to believe in every sign and omen, but will never listen to logic, reason, or criticism."
medicine
"My friend Havatzelet started learning diagnostic imaging, and asked me for pictures to practice with. I gave her two pictures of women she didn't know: my husband's mother and his friend from the north of the country. About the picture of my mother-in-law, she said that she felt a black void, especially in the abdominal area, and she really had passed away from colon cancer. About the picture of the friend, she said: 'This girl has trouble getting pregnant, but I feel contractions in my uterus. I feel like she's pregnant now.' I called and found out, and she really was pregnant, but it didn't last.
"Later, the friend from the north left us a message saying she had bad news. Havatzel turned to her pendulum and said: 'Her husband has decided to break up the package and they are getting divorced. I see a court.' A week and a half later, we learned that her husband had indeed decided to leave unexpectedly."
(Michal, architect)
"I put myself into meditation and then I can see different colors and feel if the picture is too warm," says Havatzelet Kobrovsky, who reads the pictures. "I have a crystal pendulum, and I ask it questions. It spins, and I can understand its answers. I also do family counseling using pictures and use numerology. When were you born?"
4.2.77 "Is it true that you sometimes have a hard time making decisions?"
Tara is not thrilled with the achievement: "I know a lot of people who can take a picture and read illnesses through it. Illnesses are the easiest, because they happen in the physical body, but you can also see the potential for illnesses at different energetic levels."
"All these stories have one thing in common," says Prof. Lipson sadly. "Something in the story goes against what is known in science. That's why it's mystical. According to science, you can't read pictures. So either the science is wrong or the story is wrong. The difference between scientific facts and apparent facts that contradict science is that scientific facts are tested and tried from every angle. In contrast, none of these stories have stood the scientific test."
"When my daughter was six years old, she suffered from strep throat very often. An ENT doctor recommended penicillin injections, and I had already bought the stuff, but the nurse told me that the girl would need preparation, because the injection was painful. My son, who was four at the time, also had a speech problem, which greatly interfered with his kindergarten. I decided I had nothing to lose and took them to a healer named Maurice.
"During the treatments, I was with the children in the room. The healer did not touch my daughter, nor did he use any device, and my daughter cried in pain. His hands were about thirty centimeters from her. Sometimes he came a little closer. Once, when I was holding her and he was treating her neck, which was close to mine, I felt warmth from his hands. When he treated my child, the child said he felt ticklish inside. The improvement in his speech was noticeable from session to session, and after five treatments he began to speak normally. Two years have passed since the treatments and my daughter has only gotten strep throat once."
(Dana, accountant)
Leah, the wife of healer (energy healer) Morris, explains how it works: "Maurice transfers energy to the body. He has an X-ray in his eyes, which allows him to see the hidden. When someone comes in with a tumor, he can see where it is and what size it is, and transfer focused energy to the place itself. He knows how to direct people, to make them self-aware. As Morris says: 'The body and mind are one.' When there is a serious mental problem, the body speaks."
Prof. Dov Lichtenberg, deputy dean of the Faculty of Medicine, does not dismiss the matter out of hand: "We do not understand all physical forces. I think it is appropriate to investigate the miraculous beyond our control, because we cannot understand everything."
Prof. Ori suggests an experiment. "The problem is that these children have no control group," he says. "To test the issue seriously, you need to take a large group of children with recurrent throat infections, who have been suffering from this and that for so and so many years, give ten antibiotics, give ten vitamins, soak ten in hot water, and take ten to a healer. That's the way to test, certainly not based on an anecdotal story. We will never know whether the girl, for example, did not stop getting sick simply because adults are less sensitive, or simply out of a belief that the treatment helps. Science and medicine have no basis for believing that there is a person in the universe whose energies are leaking out of their hands. If this phenomenon were measurable, they would have discovered it by now."
The mother says she felt heat emanating from his hands.
"I think it was very strong autosuggestion. This is what she expected to feel, and this is what she felt."
Yanai doesn't think everything needs to be explained: "The burden of proof is on the narrator. I'm willing to give him credit that it really happened. People who are in trouble are those who think that the rationality of the world is compromised if it's impossible to give an answer to everything, but it's possible to leave an entire field of one-off events unexplained. Science has no obligation to provide an answer to every vanity and bad mood, and there's no need to get excited about things that don't have an answer. It's a serious mistake to try to refute such stories with scientific tools. Scientists are not the Oracle of Delphi."
Questions and Answers
What do researchers say about dreams that come true?
Prof. Dov Lichtenberg says that most dreams about disasters do not come true, so the stories of their fulfillment are a coincidence. Dr. David Green adds that people interpret dreams in light of events that happened after them, and that they tend to add to and correct the memory of the dream.
How do researchers explain the personal details that fortune tellers and Kabbalists knew?
Prof. Kedma Bar-Eli suspects that the person himself gives details and hints during the meeting, and that it is also possible to deduce things from the person's appearance. Prof. Yoel Donhin explains that this is a guess, and that his chances of success are about fifty percent.
What does Prof. Shneur Lipson say about astrology?
He says that physics and astronomy cannot explain how a constellation of stars affects a person's fate, and neither can chemistry and biology. He says that psychology remains, describing magical thinking that is similar to scientific thinking but lacks control.
Why does Prof. Avi Ori say that it is impossible to learn from the story about the healer that the treatment helped?
He says that the children described do not have a control group, so it is impossible to know whether they recovered thanks to the treatment. He suggests testing this in an experiment with a large group of children with recurrent throat infections, who will receive different treatments.
What does Zvi Yanai say about trying to explain personal experiences in science?
Yanai says that it is impossible to prove that a personal experience is incorrect, so there is no point in arguing about it. According to him, science is not obligated to provide an answer to every one-off story.
The Hayadan website was part of the IOL portal of the Haaretz Group until 2002.
More on this subject on Hayadan.com - Science news
- Do souls and ghosts exist? What does science say about séances, mediums, and clinical death?
- Supersensory perception: between faith and science
- Haunted world / Coincidence indeed?
- Why do people believe in ghosts and amulets? Because they want to believe
- What would Carl Sagan say about the reader in the cafe who extorted a million shekels from a customer
2 comments
All the stories are nonsense, the only impressive thing is the séance.
I have never participated in a séance, and I don't know if the tellers are telling the truth or liars, but if they are telling the truth, then the explanations are really inadequate.
Today there are very few Kabbalists, the majority of them receive money more than they accept Kabbalists, the real Kabbalist is not famous, does not accept all kinds of celebrities, sits and studies day and night and hides in the dishes, does not seek publicity. There is a problem, you want a solution, lift the poor up to heaven, say a chapter of Psalms and believe that there is a Creator of the world and everything will be fine with the help of Lord don't forget we have a father in heaven who cares for us