Elior asks: Is it possible to take a woman's egg and fertilize it with the sperm of another animal? (For example, a monkey or a leopard...)
With leopard sperm, probably not, we are far enough away from leopards that human sperm would not recognize the leopard egg and vice versa. The monkey, on the other hand, is a different matter.
The question is which ape. The gibbon, the most primitive of the apes, is close enough to us that human sperm can attach to an egg and penetrate its protective shell. In contrast, the sperm will not attach at all to an egg of a baboon or other apes. There is no theoretical obstacle, therefore, that mating between a human and a chimpanzee or gorilla will produce a fertilized egg. But will an embryo or even a living being be created from such a union? For obvious reasons, there is no experimental answer to the question. If we are to believe Pope Alexander II (as Cardinal Pietro Damianos reported in his name), then in the 11th century, the wife of an Italian nobleman gave birth to a son by the family's pet monkey, and the Holy Father saw with his own eyes the fruit of this sin, which was given the name Maimo.
The rules of ethics prohibit such hybridization
Creatures of closely related species can be mated: a mule is created from a donkey and a mare, and an orange is created from a pomelo and a tangerine. The closest creature to humans is the chimpanzee, and if there is any chance of a human-animal hybrid, it is the Humanzee – a hybrid of a human and a chimpanzee. Humans have 46 chromosomes and chimpanzees have 48. Such a numerical difference also exists between a horse and a donkey and does not prevent hybridization but does render the offspring sterile.
The closest thing to a scientific examination of the question was carried out in the 1920s by the Soviet scientist Ilya Ivanovich Ivanov, a biologist who gained fame for developing a method of artificial insemination for horses. Ivanov sought to apply his experiment to fertilize a female chimpanzee with human sperm. He received the blessing of the Soviet scientific establishment and cooperation from the French, who provided him with logistical assistance in their colony of Guinea in West Africa. Ivanov managed to inject doses of sperm into 3 female chimpanzees before the experiment was stopped and the researcher returned to his homeland, where he continued to plan hybrids that did not come to fruition due to a shortage of monkeys. Fortunately, the rules of ethics for experiments on animals and humans will not allow experiments such as Ivanov's, and we will have to look for indirect ways to answer the question.
Our last window of opportunity to find a creature close enough to have offspring with opened about 50,000 years ago when humans migrated out of Africa and found their Neanderthal relatives in Europe and the Middle East: a branch that had split from us only half a million years earlier. For about 12,000 years, humans and Neanderthals lived side by side – and successfully carried out the experiment you are asking about. 1-4% of the genome of non-Africans is of Neanderthal origin. So it is not only possible but each of us is to some extent the product of such hybridization.
Studies from 2024 have pinpointed the date of the hybridization. An analysis of ancient and contemporary genomes, published in the journal Science (Iasi et al.), indicated that most of the Neanderthal gene flow to modern humans occurred in a single time window, approximately 50,500 to 43,500 years ago (DOIAnother study, in the journal Nature (Sümer and colleagues), who examined genomes of approximately 45,000-year-old modern humans from Germany and the Czech Republic, dated the common interbreeding of all non-Africans to approximately 45,000 to 49,000 years ago (DOI).
Can biology produce such a hybrid?
The answer is simple: Yes. There is technology that allows for the combination of genetic material from a human and an animal. The question is not what can be done, but whether it is appropriate or moral to conduct such research. In 1997, biologist Stuart Newman filed a patent application for the creation of an embryo containing cells from human and animal sources. Newman, an ideological opponent of biotechnology, did not aim to create hybrids but rather the opposite: to block the way for others to benefit from such research. Newman detailed no fewer than 36 options for manipulating embryos in the first patent application, and in nine later versions, the number reached more than 100. The Patent Office has consistently rejected all patent applications, using every substantive and formal reason the law allows, except for the reason that the patent applicant would have liked to hear: that the invention was immoral.
What is there to be afraid of?
An actual human-chimpanzee hybridization is not on the agenda: apart from the ethical problem, there is not much scientific or applied value to such an experiment. Transferring genetic material from humans to other creatures is already a reality, and human proteins such as growth hormone are produced by single-celled organisms expressing human DNA that has been inserted into them without provoking public opposition.
The creatures that some seriously plan to create and some seriously fear their appearance are not hybrids but chimeras. The name does not bode well: in mythology, the chimera is a particularly despicable monster:
"Her head is the head of a lion, her back is a dragon, in the middle is a goat
And a blade that came out of her mouth, and devoured those around him" (Homer, Iliad)
What is a chimera?
The difference between a chimera and a hybrid is that each tissue in the chimera retains the distinct characteristics of a known species. The success in identifying and growing cultures of embryonic stem cells, that is, cells that retain the ability to differentiate into any tissue in the body, makes it possible to create a pool of embryonic stem cells (blastola) mixed from two species. For example, GEEP (a combination of GOAT and SHEEP) was created, consisting of tissues derived from sheep cells and those derived from goat cells. The creature looks like a random mosaic of patches covered with sheep wool and areas of goat hair. If GEEP were allowed to reproduce, its offspring would be either full-fledged sheep or regular goats, depending on the embryonic cell from which the testicle developed.
Chimeras are important because they allow for testing and conducting experiments on human tissue in the environment of a functioning body. For example, some people are designing a pig whose liver is human and can be studied and even used for transplantation.
The main moral and religious problem is the insertion of human nerve tissue into an animal fetus. The motivation for such an operation is, for example, to test whether a "lineage" of stem cells will function when transplanted into the brain of a person suffering from a degenerative brain disease.
The argument from nature
The opponents of creating such chimeras give several types of reasons.
The first type of resistance to breaking the boundaries between species is that based on nature. According to this view, there is a limit to the degree of interference we are allowed in creation, and the creation of chimeras is a crossing of this limit. This view has its basis in the Holy Scriptures, "And God made the beast of the earth after his kind, and the cattle after their kind..." meaning that each creature belongs to "its" kind, and the Torah even explicitly prohibits hybridization: "You shall not breed with your cattle" (Leviticus 19).
But what can be done, and nature itself does not obey the rules: not only does genetic material pass between different species through viruses, chimeras also exist in nature and among humans. There are cases in which non-identical twins unite at an early stage and the result is a person carrying 2 different cell populations in his body. The argument of "naturalness" and the prohibition on man to fulfill the role of God invites the counter-argument: He who created us in his image also created in us scientific curiosity.
The boundaries between species in nature are not clear and rigid, the difference between "species" that must not be crossed and mere varieties that are permitted to be hybridized is completely unclear. It is difficult, if not impossible, to formulate a general principle according to which it is permissible to develop new agricultural varieties while creating chimeras in the laboratory is prohibited.
The housing claim
Some argue that even if the boundaries are blurred and there is no logically valid formulation, the gut feeling of disgust for "monsters" is enough to reject this technology. Intuition cannot be dismissed outright: a healthy, unreasoned repulsion often saves us from infections and dangers. The problem is that a similar argument was used, for example, by those who opposed interracial marriage. In order to establish laws, the feeling must be translated into a binding rule, and the feeling of disgust, however real and powerful, does not provide such a rule.
Human Dignity
For many generations, human society has built rules of conduct towards humans and a separate set of rules towards animals. According to Kant, an action is moral only if it stems from treating a person as an end in itself and not as a mere means. Towards animals, even if it is appropriate to prevent them from unnecessary suffering, we are allowed to treat them as instruments for our benefit. The concept of human dignity – recognition of the fundamental value that a person has by virtue of being a human being and of the obligation imposed on other people and society to treat him or her morally – is the basis for the concept of human rights and the democratic system.
The justification for devoting respect specifically to humans stems from the fact that humans have unique thinking and emotional abilities, such as the use of language, complex thinking, free choice of goals, and empathy. What about a person who does not have such thinking abilities, such as babies born with Anencephalus Or people whose brains have been severely damaged by an accident or illness? Such people are entitled to "human dignity" by virtue of their biological affiliation with the species Homo sapiens, which is characterized by these abilities. In other words, the conceptual justification for preserving the human dignity of those who most need protection is the existence of a biologically well-defined group to which it is absolutely clear who belongs. Creating an intermediate group of laboratory animals who are "somewhat human," meaning that there is no solid theoretical basis for attributing to them full "human dignity," would undermine the axiomatic foundation of human rights and the institutions of society that are designed to protect them.
But is every chimera containing human brain tissue "half-human"? Supporters of the research claim that the basis for the separation between humans and animals is the set of special abilities of the human brain, which originate not in the individual nerve cell (which is very similar to the nerve cell of monkeys and other mammals) but in the size of the brain, its architecture and its unique developmental trajectory. Human nerve cells in the brains of rodents do not change anything in the intelligence or behavior of the animal because they function as "building blocks" of a completely different structure and the threat to the definition of humanity is no greater than in the case of a person who has been implanted with a pig's heart valve.
Some go even further and claim that the goal of science is actually to examine and undermine accepted definitions and that blurring the artificial boundary between human and animal will allow us, for example, to address the fate of animals on farms in a more "humane" and logical manner.
So how far can we stretch the boundaries of legitimate research? In the opinion of philosopher Robert Streiffer, the criterion should be the interest of the creature we created. If we do endow a monkey with mental abilities similar to those of a human, then its moral status will change, and experiments on it will be treated as experiments on humans that require informed consent. The problem, of course, is that such a requirement makes the entire research unnecessary: we will learn nothing from a chimera that is not a laboratory animal. In addition, as other researchers point out, "human abilities" can also be imparted to monkeys through learning, and they may be entitled to human rights even without human brain cells in their skulls.
As of 2021, we probably won't see human minds trapped in animal bodies in the coming years, but the very theoretical consideration of this possibility illustrates how artificial and fragile the definitions and basic assumptions on which human culture is built are.
The article was updated in October 2026 to reflect two studies from 2024 that accurately dated the interbreeding between humans and Neanderthals.
Questions and Answers
Is it possible to fertilize a human egg with the sperm of another animal?
According to the article, with leopard sperm, probably not, because leopards are too far away from us. There is no theoretical obstacle to the possibility that mating between a human and a chimpanzee or gorilla will produce a fertilized egg, but for ethical reasons there is no experimental answer to the question of whether an embryo or a living being will be created.
Were humans already the product of interbreeding between species?
Yes. According to the article, humans and Neanderthals lived side by side and produced offspring, and 1% to 4% of the genomes of non-Africans are of Neanderthal origin.
What is the difference between a hybrid and a chimera?
A hybrid is a creature created by the fertilization of two species, while in a chimera each tissue retains distinct characteristics of a known species. A chimera, for example, is created by combining embryonic stem cells from two species, such as the GEEP, which consists of sheep and goat tissues.
Why are some people opposed to creating chimeras with human tissue?
Opponents rely on the claim that there is a limit to intervention in nature, on the feeling of disgust for "monsters" and on the fear that creating animals that are "somewhat human" will undermine the concept of human dignity. Proponents argue that the boundaries between species are not rigid and that human nerve cells in a rodent's brain do not change its behavior.
Did an interesting, intriguing, strange, delusional or funny question occur to you? send toppgad@pucrs.br
More on this subject on Hayadan.com - Science news
- grow human organs in the bodies of animals
- Not a prehistoric romance: New study undermines the story of Neanderthals and Sapiens “love”
- About dragons, chimeras and clocks - special questions and answers
- Scientists in the UK are seeking to produce hybrid embryos containing human and cow DNA
- A debate about the necessity of developing a mouse with human genetic data for laboratory experiments
7 comments
I had thoughts that the experiment had already been done and we received Likud voters, but it seems that many have already done this before. I wonder what a hybrid between bonobos and humans would give. Chimpanzees are not nice while bonobos solve problems and the females decide….
I would gladly make it very difficult for me during the experiment to live as a human being, but I would like a dna tag from my dog
Seriously Yoram - get out of the lab and go to many places here in Israel - the Sachnah, the Yarkon Park, the Jerusalem beach and you will see a lot of hybrids of monkeys and humans.
And the worst is that they multiply. Much!!
Surely there is a hybrid creature of man and monkey. This is my neighbor!
One look at Oren Hazan and you realize that the experiment has already been done.
What is the question?!?!? It is called a government of national reconciliation and its descendants are attributed miraculous virtues of super-intelligence, absolute honesty, social justice and economic efficiency. There is even a retired president who received an Israeli patent for the original invention and is nominated for the Nobel Prize for naivety.
In the name of religion and fear, we avoid a constant and stubborn pursuit of technological achievements. It's a shame that in the name of philosophical ideas and peppery platitudes we prevent the curiosity of scientists from bearing fruit. The rule of not causing suffering is enough. Don't be mean. Act in favor of building knowledge and minimize any possible damage or suffering to both animals and humans.