Corbus asks: In human culture there is a taboo on sexual relations between family members, but in animals there is not. For example, it is not uncommon for a cat to impregnate its biological mother. Does incest really lead to the birth of "defective" offspring?
Incest does indeed increase the chance of genetic defects. A mutation is a random change in genetic material and it occurs from time to time in each of us. Billions of "letters" make up the genome, and any copying error that occurs during cell division is a mutation. Each of us has several dozen defective genes, some of which are fatal defects. What protects us are the spare genes. Each gene appears in us at least twice: once from the hereditary cargo of the egg and once from what the sperm brought with it, and almost always one healthy copy is enough for us. We are in trouble when the same defective gene appears in both the sperm and the egg, and of course the likelihood of such an event occurring increases the greater the genetic similarity between the mother and father. This is the biological basis for the reluctance to incest.
But two false assumptions are hidden in the question. First, taboo is not unique to us, we are not so different from our fellow creatures: they too have mechanisms to prevent incest. Second, our taboo is far from being perfect or even stronger than that of animals.
The plant kingdom is built around preventing separation from self-pollination
As mentioned, mechanisms that prevent incest exist in animals and plants. In the plant kingdom, several mechanisms have evolved to prevent self-pollination, that is, fertilization of the eggs with pollen from the same plant. Some species have developed dioecy, meaning that the entire plant will bear only male or only female flowers. This is the case, for example, in date palms. Monoecious plants, in which flowers of both sexes are found on the same plant, or there are stamens and ovules in one flower (bisexual plant), avoid self-pollination by separating the time between the maturation of the sperm cells and the egg cells (as in avocado trees), or the anatomical structure of the pistil and pollen does not allow such "incest" (as in cyclamen flowers). There are also plants that do not shy away from self-fertilization, including wheat.
Animals: Prevention Mechanisms in Nature
In the animal world, we see around us female domestic cats impregnating their siblings, but in the cat's ancestors, the kittens that reached maturity separated from each other and wandered far away. The chance that a wild cat will actually meet her sibling during the breeding season is very small, and therefore there is no motivation to develop an instinctive aversion to incest. In nature, males migrate farther when they reach maturity, thus further reducing the chance of an awkward family reunion. In domestic animals, migration stops at the yard fence or the bars of the cage, resulting in hybrids that would not be likely in nature.
“Family values” that prevent incest have evolved in animals in dense groups. This requires mechanisms that allow the animal to recognize relatives. Chimpanzees, our closest relatives, can match images of foreign chimpanzee mothers to their children based on facial similarities, and this ability helps them avoid incest. Mice avoid having sex with a partner if their urine smells too similar to their own.
Genetic studies have also shown that incest is very rare in birds. In a long-term study of a dense population of sparrows on an isolated island, where it is impossible to get away from relatives, researchers identified only 9 cases of incest over a period of 16 years (it is likely that a study of a human population of a similar size would have yielded many more cases). The cases that did occur were always between a mother and her son, or between a sister and her brother, whose appearance and voice have changed since he grew wings and flew. They were never between a father and his daughter, because the adult's appearance and singing style do not change, and the female will avoid mating with a male whose appearance and voice are too similar to those she saw and heard from her father when she was in the nest.
The female is more reluctant than the male to the possibility of incest, because the burden of carrying damaged offspring falls on her. Therefore, the female sparrow will be more careful to avoid contact with her father than the male will be to avoid mating with his mother or sister.
The Naked Rat: Exceptional
Every rule has an exception. In arid regions of Africa, a strange animal burrows: the naked mole-rat. These blind rodents live in underground burrows and hardly ever come out. In those isolated burrows, a unique form of reproduction has evolved, which only two closely related species of African mole-rats of all mammals require. In this organization, reminiscent of ant colonies and bee hives, only one female in a group is fertile and only one male fertilizes her. All other members of the group are first-degree relatives and are not sexually active at all.
The naked mole rat is perhaps the only mammal in which the taboo on incest has disappeared: when the queen dies, one of the workers will become a queen and one of her brothers will fertilize her. The genetic similarity between the members of the colony is even greater than that between worker bees in a hive. In such a situation, any genetic defect would be fatal, but a population that has survived for several generations will be free of defects and therefore not be affected by incest.
The second species of mole-rat (Damaraland mole-rat) has preserved, even under extreme conditions of isolation, the universal taboo. When the queen dies, there is no reproduction until a foreign female arrives by chance, an event which may occur only years later or not at all. Only then, when reproduction without incest is possible, will one of the males take on the role of father and the joy of sex returns to the den.
And what about us?
In humans, a psychological mechanism named after Edvard Westermarck prevents us from feeling sexual attraction to those who grew up with us in childhood, usually brothers and sisters. A study of children raised in kibbutz children's homes found that there are almost no marriages between members of the same kibbutz, and there are no couples at all who grew up in the same children's home during the critical period: up to the age of 6. In accordance with Westermarck's theory, the list of prohibitions on incest in the Quran is quite short but includes "your nursing sisters," meaning those who were suckled by the same wet nurse and grew up side by side in the first years of life.
The psychological barrier is not absolute, and its weakness is evidenced by numerous cases of incest between a father and his daughter or between an adult brother and his younger sister. As with animals, the human female is more sophisticated and cautious than the male, and cases of incest, whether between a mother and her son or between an adult sister and a younger brother, are very rare. In a study in which subjects were asked to imagine sexual relations with people of varying degrees of kinship and to report their reaction (from disgust to attraction), it was found that women extended their reluctance from family members to close friends as well, in other words, they created a kind of emotional safety zone.
Man is allowed - culture
But we must remember what distinguishes us from cats, sparrows, or avocado trees: culture. Human taboos are flexible and change from time to time. Since the barrier to sexual attraction is created when children grow up together throughout childhood, in polygamous societies (where one man has multiple wives) an attraction can certainly arise between paternal half-siblings, each of whom is raised by a different mother with her children.
The first recorded instance of such an attraction appears in the book of 2 Samuel. Amnon, the eldest son of King David, falls in love with his half-sister Tamar, David's daughter by another woman. The lack of close contact in childhood makes her psychologically unrelated, and indeed Amnon describes her not as his sister but as the sister of Absalom (his brother by the same father and mother): "I love Tamar, my brother Absalom's sister." Tamar herself, when attacked by Amnon, does not see the sexual relationship as a violation of the law: "And she said to him, 'No, my brother, do not trouble me, for such a thing would not be done in Israel: do not do this to this worthless woman...and now Speak, please, to the king, for he will not keep me from you."
The Book of Genesis provides a wealth of events that today we would define as incest. Terah's three sons: Abraham, Haran, and Norah, create a lineage that is every geneticist's nightmare. Abraham marries Sarah, his half-sister on Terah's side: "She is my sister, the daughter of my father, and not the daughter of my mother; and she became my wife," while Nahor marries Milcah, the daughter of his brother Haran. In the next generation, Isaac marries Rebekah, the granddaughter of Nahor and Milcah, and their son Jacob marries Rachel and Leah, the daughters of his cousin Laban the Aramean.
Jewish law not only permits the marriage of cousins, but the Sages even encourage such marriages: "He who loves his God and brings his relatives closer, and who marries his sister's daughter and lends a rock to the poor in their time of distress, the Scripture says, 'Then you shall call, and the Lord will answer.'" In Hellenistic Egypt, brother-sister marriage was the norm in the royal family. Cleopatra VII (the beloved of Julius Caesar and Antony) not only married her brother, but was the daughter of Cleopatra V and her brother Ptolemy XII, and the grandfather and grandmother were also siblings, so Cleopatra had only one great-grandmother and one great-grandfather.
In some human societies, marriage between relatives, usually cousins, is a common practice, despite the increased risk of birth defects. Some speculate that marriage between relatives was advantageous in conditions of high exposure to infectious diseases. In such situations, it is sometimes advantageous not for a single gene but for a set of genes that confers resistance to the disease agent. If such a beneficial set of genes is common in a family, there will be an advantage for those who preserve it, that is, who will bring into the world offspring with their relatives. Comparative research between different cultures has shown that marriage between relatives is indeed a more common practice in areas where infectious diseases are a significant cause of death.
A clear correlation between the failure of state institutions and the level of intermarriage (which creates clans)
In the modern world, where infectious diseases are often easily prevented or treated, such adaptation is no longer valuable and is harmful. But the damage is not only health-related: countries with high rates of consanguineous marriage are also those that struggle to build functioning democratic institutions. When cousin marriage is not accepted, genetic kinship and with it family commitment are diluted with each generation. Most of us barely know second cousins, and we are unlikely to recognize a fourth cousin on the street. In such a society, a person is forced to form social, professional, commercial, and political connections that are not based on family ties, and accordingly learn to trust people, organizations, and institutions.
In societies where the family tree is less fragmented, relatives are also neighbors, partners, and friends. In such societies, it is difficult for institutions shared by the entire population, such as the judiciary, civil service, media, trade unions, and political parties, to gain the trust and cooperation of the public. Cross-cultural comparative research reveals a clear correlation between consanguineous marriage and the failure to build stable democratic institutions.
The Catholic Church prohibits the marriage of cousins.
In the fifth century AD, the Western Roman Empire collapsed and the continent was taken over by the barbarians: warring tribes such as the Huns, Vandals, Franks, and Goths. The social structure of these tribes is reminiscent of the institution of the extended family (عشيرة) in Bedouin society. The Roman historian Tacitus describes the barbarian tribe in which the heads of the family are also the legislators, judges, and military commanders, and in which family members are obligated to "take upon themselves the disputes of their father or blood relatives and the bonds of their friendship." It is difficult to imagine a value system more contrary to that of the rule of law, and yet the descendants of these barbarians were, about 1,000 years later, the founders of the first states, and as of 2022 they are a model of functioning democracies.
Some see the initial development towards a modern state in a conference of Catholic bishops that met in 506 in the city of Agde, France. The decisions of the conference dealt mainly with the conduct of priests and the prohibition of the sale of church lands, but one paragraph in the margins of the decisions prohibited the marriage of cousins. Later, the Catholic Church in the West extended the prohibition to seventh cousins. The Byzantine Empire adopted a prohibition on the marriage of cousins in 692, and the Eastern churches did not extend the prohibition beyond first cousins (common grandfather).
The impact of this ruling was not immediate, but over the generations, the rate of consanguineous marriage steadily declined, the power of the extended family declined, and at the same time the power of formal institutions and public legal systems increased. Comparative historical research has shown a correlation between the length of time a society weaned itself from consanguineous marriage and the growth of state institutions that would form the basis of a democratic regime, and even the degree of democracy in modern societies.
Did an interesting, intriguing, strange, delusional or funny question occur to you? sent to ppgad@pucrs.br
Questions and Answers
Does incest increase the chance of genetic defects?
Yes. Each person has several dozen defective genes, and usually one good copy of the gene protects us. When parents are genetically close, the likelihood that the same defective gene will appear in both of them and be passed on to the offspring increases.
Do animals abstain from incest?
Usually yes. In the wild, young migrate and separate, and many species recognize relatives by facial features, scent, or sound, such as chimpanzees, mice, and sparrows. The naked mole rat is an exception, living in isolated groups where only one pair breeds.
What is the Westermarck effect in humans?
This is a psychological mechanism that prevents sexual attraction to those we grew up with in childhood, usually brothers and sisters. A study of children on kibbutzim found that there is almost no marriage between those who grew up together in a children's home until the age of 6.
Why is consanguineous marriage harmful to society according to the article?
Aside from the health risk, comparative studies have found a significant correlation between high rates of consanguineous marriage and difficulty in building stable democratic institutions. In such societies, trust is centered on the extended family rather than shared institutions.
What role did the Catholic Church play in prohibiting cousin marriage?
A council of bishops in 506 forbade cousin marriage, and the church later extended the ban to seventh cousins. Comparative historical research has found a correlation between the length of time a society weaned itself off consanguineous marriage and the growth of democratic state institutions.
More on this subject on Hayadan.com - Science news
- Ancient DNA reveals how a new society was built after the fall of Rome
- The naked rat develops the survival properties of a plant in the absence of oxygen
- What is disgust?
- Is it possible to create a hybrid of a human and a monkey? On hybrids, chimeras, and ethical questions
5 comments
This explains the backwardness of the Arab societies.
Economics student
Don't take the Bible stories too seriously...
Two comments:
1. The writer states that: "First, the taboo is not unique to us, we are not so different from our fellow creatures: they also have prevention mechanisms for incest. Second, our taboo is far from perfect or even stronger than the animals'."
Both assertions do not really emerge from the article.
As far as the plant kingdom is concerned - a minority of the flora is dioecious, and even with regard to this minority it is not clear that dioeciousness stems precisely from avoiding incest. In most plants, which are monoecious, it seems that the phenomenon of promiscuity is prevalent. Also, in certain plants where the mechanisms of separation in ripening times and differences in the anatomical structure exist - it is likely that the mechanisms may not be precise enough. Therefore, incest is a fairly common phenomenon in the plant kingdom.
In the animal kingdom - the only real evidence for an inherent instinctual avoidance of incest is from the population of sparrows on an isolated island and the Damaraland Mole Rat species. In all other cases, with the possible exception of the chimpanzees, it is quite clear that the avoidance of incest is a fortuitous outcome of certain behavior patterns dependent on the environment, and not an inherent instinctual trait.
2. The writer states "Tamar herself, when she is attacked by Absalom, does not see the sexual relationship as a violation of the law".
Of course this statement is not correct. The fact that Tamar suggests to Amnon, "Now speak to the king, because he will not keep me from you." does not indicate that Tamar believed that Amnon's act was not a violation of the law, since as far as she was concerned, "this scoundrel will not do it in Israel". She offered her proposal "Speak to the king, because he will not keep me from you" just to comfort herself in the problematic situation she found herself in and to thwart Amnon's terrible act (this is how Habarbanal interprets it, in his completely rational and reasonable interpretation). Absalom's later response also indicates how wrong the act was in terms of the law, although it did not justify the act of murder that Absalom committed.
There was a price for the close marriage of the fathers.
barrenness!
Out of 4 mothers, 3 mothers were completely infertile
A problem that disappeared with Jacob's sons who stop marrying relatives and almost all marry Canaanites (except Joseph who marries an Egyptian)
I understand that close marriages simply reinforce certain genes.
not only of diseases.
Also good genes for strength, endurance, abilities and intelligence